Asphalt shingles vs Metal roofing which is the best option for me? Well there’s a few questions that need to be answered before you make a decision. What is most important to you when it comes to your roof?
Is longevity and durability the most important? What about budget? Maybe it’s how the final product will look? Aesthetic? Whatever it may be in this short read you will find out a few pros and cons of the two roofing systems.
Now before we get into it. Both of these systems are great options for your home’s. When installed correctly they will both look great and keep the water out, ensuring that everything inside is safe and dry. So when you’re doing your research for your next roof replacement and if you decide to go with one of these in the future it’s great to know the tradeoffs for each.
ASPHALT SHINGLES
Asphalt shingles, the most common roofing system on the market. If you drive through any neighborhood and look up, almost all the home’s have an asphalt shingle installed on them. Here are 3 pros and cons for this particular roofing material.
3 Pros of Asphalt Shingles:
- Cost Effective: Asphalt shingles are the less costly option when it comes to roofing materials. Making these the perfect option for homeowners who want an awesome looking roof protecting their home. Without having to break the bank.
- Efficient Install: With the ease of install, crews are efficient in installing this product. Most home’s only take 1 day to complete. So you as the homeowner don’t have to deal with the noise that comes with installing for too long.
- Options: Asphalt shingles are very versatile, giving you many options to customize your home to your liking. Various colors, class 3 shingles, class 4 impact resistant shingles, and designer weather resistant shingles.
3 Cons of Asphalt Shingles:
- Longevity: Up here in the northern climates we get snow and ice dams during winter and hail storms in the warmer months, all taking a toll on the shingles decreasing the lifespan. Most of the time the shingles should realistically last about 15-20 years. And depending on how long you live in that home you might have to replace the roof more than once.
- More Maintenance: Again on longevity, as the homeowner you will have to do more upkeep and maintenance with this system. Cleaning your gutters out every year, cleaning debris off the roof, and getting it inspected every couple of years.
- More Susceptible To Weather Events: Strong winds and hail. When it storms asphalt shingles are more vulnerable to get damaged. Causing a need for replacement sooner.
STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF
Standing seam metal roofing is the premier product when it comes to roofing system. Becoming more and more popular year after year. Here are 3 pros and cons of standing seam metal.
3 Pros of Standing Seam Metal
- Lifetime System: A properly installed metal roofing system should last you about 40-50 years. Making it basically a one time thing to replace. Eliminating the concern of having to plan out or think about another roof replacement.
- Durable: The thickness of the gauge of metal makes this a great protector against storms. Larger hail stones will be needed to cause damage to the metal.
- Sleek Design: Once installed the finished product looks clean cut. Giving your home an amazing modern look. The aesthetically pleasing look boosts the curb appeal standing out from home’s without meal systems.
3 Cons of Standing Seam Metal
- Costs: This roofing system is the most costly out on the market. The material needed and what they are made out of bumps the cost up. Also again since it’s basically a one time replacement, that also affects the cost.
- Complex Install: Since not every roofer knows how to install this type of system, you’ll need a very experienced crew who knows all the intricacies of how to install standing seam metal. This also is a big reason why it cost more.
- Noise: Something that is possible is the potential for noise when it rains. Especially if your home is not insulated properly, that can affect the noise level as well.
On a final note about Asphalt Shingles and Standing Seam Metal, there is good for both and there is cons for both. The 2 systems are great options to protect your home. It all comes down to each individual’s needs and wants. Are you planning on moving eventually or just need a roof so you can keep your insurance coverage? Then asphalt is the way to go. Is this home where you see yourself living forever in and want to boost up curb appeal? Then standing seam is your route. It’s great to know the benefits and tradeoff’s of each while you’re doing your research on deciding what type of roofing system you want next.
At Pro Works Roofing llc we help homeowners through the process, answering any questions you have.
612-434-87-91
651-492-5003
office@proworksroofing.com